Jumada al-Awwal Offer - Get 40% off on Discover Your Spouse Couple Pack! ✦ Jumada al-Awwal Offer - Get 40% off on Discover Your Spouse Couple Pack! ✦ Jumada al-Awwal Offer - Get 40% off on Discover Your Spouse Couple Pack! ✦ Jumada al-Awwal Offer - Get 40% off on Discover Your Spouse Couple Pack! ✦

Investing in the Stock Exchange – Conditions and Limits of Permissibility

By Bilal Naeem – Hiba Magazine Team Writer

A Muslim should exercise care in all aspects of his life to ensure that the principles of Islam are being followed to the best of his knowledge but where he earns his income from and what becomes the basis of provision for him and his family requires a closer look and greater diligence.

One such source for investment and return is the stock exchange. Fundamentally, investing in stocks carries the same principle of being a partner in a business venture.

The structure has changed in terms of scope but the fundamental principles remain the same for the stock exchange and a Sharakat, that is multiple parties pool in resources to share ownership (profit / loss) in a Halal business.

At the onset, some caveats are necessary for a better understanding of this discussion.

The nature of return on investment:

When anyone invests in shares, income can be earned in two ways:

  • Dividend: the return paid back by the company in proportion to your investment after a certain amount of time based on the company’s performance.
  • Capital Gain: the difference in the cost of the share when purchased and the price of the share when sold.

The legal structure of the business:

The business may be structured as a Limited Liability Company (LLC), a Modaraba, Open end or Close end mutual funds, specific instruments such as Sukuk bonds etc. There is greater depth of understanding required here which we cannot go in but some structures are closer to Islamic principles than others.

For example, the most common structure of LLC, limits personal liability and allows companies to file “bankruptcy” giving a clean chit to owners. This is against the principles of Sharakah in Islam and certain scholars have raised concerns on the validity of such a legal structure that is open to manipulation and fraud.

Conditions for permissibility of investment in Stock Exchange

For the simplicity of the broader discussion, we assume that the legal structure is compliant with Islamic principles. What impacts the permissibility of investment in shares in the stock exchange therefore relies on four core elements:

  1. The product of the company
  2. The financing and investing activities of the company
  3. Real ownership / possession of the shares
  4. The trading practices being followed by the investor

 The product of the company

Investment is impermissible in the stocks of:

  1. Companies where the core product is considered Haram in Islam such as alcohol, tobacco, gambling, adult entertainment, insurance etc.
  2. Companies where the product is linked to Riba such as banks, leasing companies, financial institutions etc.

The financing and investing activities of the company

If the company has used a Riba based source of funding (e.g. long term or short term interest bearing loans) to finance its operations, then the investment is impermissible. Similarly, if the company has excess cash and this is invested to earn return via Riba, then investing in such companies would be impermissible.

Real ownership and possession

Islam requires that you must buy actual equity (shares) representing tangible ownership in the company. The shares must be officially transferred to your name before you sell them. This means that trying to earn return via forward, futures, options, short selling or any type of day trading that does not entail actual transfer of shares and then resale as separate transactions is not permissible.

Trading practices:

In the case of earning dividend, the investor provided certain capital and earns an income from the profits of the company against said invested capital. This is a relatively straightforward investment and returns scenario.

However, in the case of capital gain the permissibility of activities and the income are more stringent, as Islam does not allow for excessive uncertainty (Gharar) or speculation (Maisir) when earning income but requires the fundamentals to be strong, i.e. the company’s business activities and performance. This effectively means that purely speculative day trading, market manipulation or “pump-and-dump” schemes or in more extreme cases, insider trading is impermissible in Islam.

Current “non-conventional” models and “purification” methodologies

Various products exist in the market and in the stock exchange that have been “brought in line” with Islamic principles such as “Islamic” banking, “Islamic” Insurance – Takaful or the like.

Similarly, a separate index exists on Pakistan’s Stock Exchange known as KSE-Meezan Index or “KMI” for short that contains “Shariah Compliant Companies” based on set criteria.

The KMI index in Pakistan considers the above factors but has set its own limits, e.g. if interest bearing debt is less than 33% of the total assets, it is considered as Shariah Compliant and permissible to be traded in KMI index.

If the company has less than 5% income generated from interest it can be traded and the investor can “purify” their dividend (not capital gains) by doing a calculation of the proportion of non-permissible income to total income and the dividend earned on it. This ratio is already calculated by various Shariah advisory groups, essentially giving a dividend purification sheet. This amount must be given away as charity but should not be counted within your Zakat obligations and should not be expected to gain Sawab.

The reader is encouraged to do his own research on the essence of such products instead of relying on the form or packaging that they are offered in.

Finally, when selecting shares to invest in, investors should adopt sound investment strategies to make well-informed decisions such as a fundamental understanding of the business of the company and focusing on analysis and long-term investment objectives rather than speculation.

And Allah (swt) knows best.